Preview

Concept: philosophy, religion, culture

Advanced search

Intelligentsia Like a Challenge: the Identity of the Russian Intelligentsia in the 21st Century

https://doi.org/10.24833/2541-8831-2020-1-13-7-20

Abstract

The article is devoted to the problem of the Russian intelligentsia identity formation in the 21st century. The authors trace a historical path that the Russian intelligentsia has gone through. Russian philosophers of the 20th century rated this path as tragic, noting that the intelligentsia itself wrote its own history, having captured it in great cultural texts well known in Russia and in the world. The need to understand oneself, one’s purpose, to understand the peculiarity of the situation in Russia and the world is an expression of the intelligentsia’s self-consciousness. Cultural memory, allowing the intelligentsia to maintain its own integrity, plays a leading role in shaping the identity of the intelligentsia. It allows for its own integrity to be maintained. The Russian intelligentsia is a socio-cultural type, including the complex mix of ideas and values which has been shaped since the end of the 18th century in difficult historical conditions. From the beginning, the intelligentsia tried to solve the problem of Russian modernization through enlightening, initiating social changes and participating in them. The Russian intelligentsia formed a special character - psychological traits and behavior, opposite to the type of European intellectuals. Until now, the Russian intelligentsia argues about itself, becoming sometimes closer to European intellectuals, but affirming sometimes its singularity. Nevertheless, in modern Russia there is a widespread perception that the intelligentsia is being replaced by a class of intellectuals - professionals, experts, and public intellectuals which strive to influence the formation of public discourse and the discourse of power. In the course of post-Soviet transformations, the intelligentsia began to lose not only the role of public and political actor, but also the role of the moral elite. The consequences of this process are destructive for younger generations and society as a whole. The study conducted by the authors of the article shows that the discourse of intelligentsia is changing as well as the discourse about it, although the intelligentsia is being constructed in a process of permanent dispute about the past, present and future of Russia. At the same time, intellectual identity is being formed in this dispute. So, it would be wrong to perceive the Russian intelligentsia as an unchanging phenomenon. Its openness to cultural and social changes allows us to talk about the formation of the intelligentsia of the 21st century. The study also reveals that the attitudes towards the intelligentsia expressed by the young generation of educated Russians living in an open, global world, are changing. The new vision of the intelligentsia is similar to its European perception as an intellectual elite. At the same time, a desire of young Russians to turn to the values historically constituting the moral code of the Russian intelligentsia, is observed. Thus, it cannot be said that the intelligentsia has disappeared from Russian public life; instead, the intelligentsia identity is a cultural challenge for the younger generation of modern Russians.

About the Authors

О. M. Zdravomyslova
International Foundation for Socio-Economic and Political studies (The Gorbachev Foundation)
Russian Federation

Olga M. Zdravomyslova – Doctor of Sciences (Philosophy); Sociologist, Executive Director

125167, Moscow, Leningradsky Prospekt, 39



N. V. Kutukova
МГИМО МИД России
Russian Federation

Natalia V. Kutukova– Associate Professor, Department of the World Literature and Culture

119454, prospect Vernadskogo 76



References

1. De Blasio A. 2014. The End of Russian Philosophy. Tradition and Transition at the Turn of the 21st Century. New York: Palgrave MacMillan. 232 p.

2. Zdravomyslova O.M., Kutukova N.V. 2010. Russian Intelligentsia Like a Challenge: Concept, Value and Identity (report). The Russian Language Outside the Nation. Edinburgh: The University of Edinburgh. 31 March – 03 April.

3. Andreeva G.M. 2005. Psihologija social’nogo poznanija [The Philosophy of Social Cognition]. Moscow: Aspekt Press. 274 p. (In Russian).

4. Berger Р., Lukman Т. 1995. Social’noe Konstruirovanie real’nosti. Traktat po sociologii znanija [The Social Construction of Reality. A Treatise on Sociology of Knowledge]. Moscow. Medium. 179 p. (In Russian).

5. Berdjaev N.A. 1990. Istoki i smysl russkogo kommunizma [The origins and meaning of Russian communism]. Moscow: Nauka. 224 р. (In Russian).

6. Fedotov G.P. (pen name Bogdanov E)1927. Tragedija intelligencii [Tragedy of the Intelligentsia]. Versty. № 2. Р. 145-184. Paris. (In Russian).

7. Florida R. 2005. Kreativnyj klass: ljudi, kotorye menjajut budushhee [The Rise of The Creative Class and How It’s Transforming Work, Leisure, Community and Everyday Life]. Moscow. Klassika-XXI. 430 p. (In Russian).

8. Gasparov M.L. 1996. Jazyk, pamjat’, obraz. Lingvistika jazykovogo sushhestvovanija [Language, Memory, Image. Linguistics of Linguistic Existence]. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 21 p. (In Russian).

9. Kak zhivesh’, intelligencija? 2018. Sociologicheskie ocherki: kollektivnaja monografija [How do you live, intelligentsia? Sociological essays: collective monograph]. Otv. red. Zh.T. Toshhenko. Moscow: Centr social’nogo prognozirovanija i marketinga. 202 p. (In Russian).

10. Mezhuev 2000. V.M. Traditsija samovlastija v sovremennoj Rossii [Tradition of Autocracy in Modern Russia]. Kuda idet Rossia. Vlast’, ostshestvo, lichnost’. Moscow. Intertsentr. Р. 81-92 (In Russian).

11. Mezhuev V.M. 2006. Idea cul’tury [The Idea of Culture]. Moscow: Progress-Tradition. 408 р. (In Russian).

12. Prigov D.A. 2004. O nih, o shestidesjatnikah, o rodimyh! [About Them, about Sixties, about Dears!]. Iskusstvo kino. № 5. P. 37-40 (In Russian).

13. Sviridov V.P. 2010. Rol ‘ intelligencii v uslovijah transformacii sovremennogo rossijskogo obshhestva [The Role of Intellectuals in the Transformation of Modern Russian Society]. Vestnik Moskovskogo gosudarstvennogo oblastnogo universiteta. Serija Istorija i politicheskie nauki. № 3. 154-158 (In Russian).

14. Shestidesjatniki [Sixties]. 2007. Sbornik statej. Moscow: Fond Liberal’naja missija. 208 р. (In Russian).

15. Voz’mitel’ A.A. 2019. Stanovlenie i smysly zhizni sovetskoj intelligencii. Sud’by rossijskoj intelligencii: proshloe, nastojashhee, budushhee [The Formation and Meanings of the Life of the Soviet Intelligentsia. The Fate of the Russian Intelligentsia: Past, Present, Future]. XX Mezhdunarodnaja teoretiko-metodologicheskaja konferencija, RGGU. 9 aprelja 2019 goda: sbornik statej pod redakciej Zh.T. Toshhenko; redaktor-sostavitel’ D.G. Cybikova; RGGU, Sociologicheskij fakul’tet, Centr sociologicheskih issledovanij. Moscow: RGGU. P. 72-79 (In Russian).

16. Yakovleva M.N. 2019. Rossijskoe gosudarstvo glazami sovremennoj intelligencii. Sud’by rossijskoj intelligencii: proshloe, nastojashhee, budushhee [Russian State through the Eyes of the Modern Intelligentsia. The Fate of the Russian intelligentsia: Past, Present, Future]. XX Mezhdunarodnaja teoretiko-metodologicheskaja konferencija, RGGU, 9 apr. 2019 g. Sbornik statej pod obshh. red. Zh.T. Toshhenko; red.-sost. D.G. Cybikova. Sociologicheskij fakul’tet, Centr sociologicheskih issledovanij. Moscow: RGGU. P. 211-221 (In Russian).

17. Zdravomyslova O.M., Kutukova N.V. 2009. Intelligencija kak cennost’ «russkogo mira»: k probleme istoricheskogo i kul’turnogo kontekstov v obuchenii russkomu jazyku. Russkij jazyk — posrednik v dialoge kul’tur. [Intelligentsia as the value of the «Russian world»: to the problem of historical and cultural contexts in learning Russian language]. [Russian Language – Mediator in the Dialogue of Cultures]. Mezhdunarodnaja nauchno-metodicheskaja konferencija 19-20 fevralja 2009 g. Moscow: MGIMO-University. P. 30-39 (In Russian).


Review

For citations:


Zdravomyslova О.M., Kutukova N.V. Intelligentsia Like a Challenge: the Identity of the Russian Intelligentsia in the 21st Century. Concept: philosophy, religion, culture. 2020;4(1):7-20. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2541-8831-2020-1-13-7-20

Views: 746


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2541-8831 (Print)
ISSN 2619-0540 (Online)