Shadows of the Past in Spain: Historical Policy and Collective Memory of Civil War and Francism

The article is devoted to the study of the phenomenon of public memory about the civil war of 1936 – 1939 and the Francoist dictatorship in Spain. Another focus of the research is an analysis of the difficulties and contradictions associated with the transformations of the Spanish state historical policy, including the problems resulting from the adoption of a new law on democratic memory in the country. For twenty years, issues of memory have invariably been present in the Spanish political discourse and affect the daily life of Spaniards. This situation has been accompanied by significant media attention and wide media coverage. Numerous references to the themes of memory and the difficult past are often superficial and do not reveal the essence of the problem, forming a horizontal informational reflection that gives the illusion of saturation. The authors, analyzing the relationship of the Spaniards with their past, apply the comparative method in the context of four historical stages — the period of the Francoist dictatorship, the stage of democratic transition, democratic Spain in the 1980s – 1990s, and Spain of the 21st century. The conducted research allows us to assert that one important characteristic of the Spanish case is the lack of social consolidation and acceptance of the policy of public memory on a democratic basis. This reveals the difficulty of building a social and political consensus around the policy of memory. Turning to the history of the issue of the return of memory and noting the desire of the left political forces for a historical revenge, the authors of the article conclude that it is impossible to present a single correct presentation of democratic memory. Using the example of the denial of both the Francoist memory and the revolutionary memory of the anarchist movement, the article argues the specific character of democratic memory as a cultural phenomenon: democratic memory is multiple, it reflects and presents various interests of many social actors and does not have an exclusively liberal-democratic character.

1. Aguilar Fernández, P. (1996) Memoria y olvido de la guerra civil española. Madrid: Alianza.

2. Aguilar Fernández, P. (2008) Políticas de la Memoria y Memorias de la Política. El caso español en perspectiva comparada. Madrid: Alianza Editorial.

3. Aróstegui, J. and Gálvez Biesca, S. (2010) Generaciones y memoria de la represión franquista: un balance de los movimientos por la memoria. Valencia: Universitat de Valencia.

4. Aróstegui, J. and Godicheau, F. (2006) Guerra Civil: mito y memoria. Madrid: Marcial Pons.

5. Assmann, A. (2006) Der lange Schatten der Vergangenheit: Erinnerungskultur und Geschichtspolitik. München: C.H. Beck. (Russ. ed.: (2014) Dlinnaya ten’ proshlogo: Memorial’naya kul’tura i istoricheskaya politika. Moscow: Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie Publ.).

6. Bernecker, W. L. and Brinkmann, S. (2006) Kampf der Erinnerungen. Der Spanische Bürgerkrieg in Politik und Gesellschaft 1936–2006. Nettersheim: Verlag Graswurzelrevolution.

7. Bukharmedova, L. M. and Grantseva, E. O. (2014) ‘Perekhod ot frankizma k demokratii [The transition from Francoism to democracy]’, in Istoriya Ispanii. T. 2. Ot voyny za ispanskoye nasledstvo do nachala XXI veka. [History of Spain. Vol. 2. From the War of the Spanish Succession to the beginning of the XXI century]. Moscow: Indrik Publ, pp. 623–635. (In Russian).

8. Calleja, J. M. and Casanova, J. (2018) El Valle de los Caídos. Barcelona: Espasa.

9. Castro, L. (2008) Héroes y caídos. Políticas de la memòria en la España contemporánea. Madrid: La Catarata.

10. Cuesta, J. (2008) La Odisea de la memoria: historia de la memoria en España: siglo XX. Madrid: Alianza.

11. Encarnación, O. G. (2014) Democracy without justice in Spain: the politics of forgetting. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

12. Epple, N. (2020) Neudobnoye proshloye: pamyat’ o gosudarstvennykh prestupleniyakh v Rossii i drugikh stranakh [An inconvenient past: the memory of state crimes in Russia and other countries]. Moscow: Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie Publ. (In Russian).

13. Espinosa Maestre, F. (2006) Contra el olvido: historia y memoria de la guerra civil. Barcelona: Crítica.

14. Fedorov, A. Y. (2016) ‘Repressive Policy durring and after the Spanish Civil War: History and Contoversy’, Historical Expertise, (4), pp. 45–66. (In Russian).

15. Garzón, B. (2011) La fuerza de la razón. Barcelona: Debate.

16. González Calleja, E. (2013) Memoria e historia: Vademécum de conceptos y debates fundamentales. Madrid: Libros de la Catarata.

17. Grantseva, E. (2019) ‘An Ideology Captured in Architecture. Valley of the Fallen and Other Projects of the Franco Regime’, Latin-american Historical Almanac, 24, pp. 105–122. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.32608/2305-8773-2019-24-1-105-122

18. Grantseva, E. O. (2018) ‘Is an Agreement Possible? Historical Memory of the Events of the 20th Century in the Daily Life and Legislation of Modern Spain’, Latin-american Historical Almanac, 19(1), pp. 316–336. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.32608/2305-8773-2018-19-1-316-336

19. Grantseva, E. O. (2020) ‘Guerra Civil en España de 1936-1939 en el discurso público del segundo franquismo y la España actual’, in Rossiya i Iberoamerika v globaliziruyushchemsya mire: istoriya i sovremennost’ [Russia and Iberoamerica in a Globalizing World: Past and Present]: Conference Proceedings. Saint Petersburg: Skifia-print, pp. 1731–1738.

20. Juliá Díaz, S. (coord.) (1999) Víctimas de la Guerra Civil. Madrid: Temas de Hoy.

21. Juliá Díaz, S. (2003) ‘Echar al olvido: Memoria y amnistía en la transición’, Claves de razón práctica, (129), pp. 14–25.

22. Julía Díaz, S. (dir.) (2006) Memoria de la guerra y del franquismo. Madrid: Fundación Pablo Iglesias.

23. Khenkin, S. M. (2019a) ‘Spain: Controversy around Historical Memory’, Outlines of global transformations: politics, economics, law, 12(4), pp. 72–87. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.23932/2542-0240-2019-12-4-72-87

24. Khenkin, S. (2019b) ‘Present-Day Spain: Several Problems of Addressing Civil War and Dictatorship’, ISTORIYA, 10(2). (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.18254/S207987840002533-5

25. Koroleva, A. A. (2020) ‘Museificación y medios de comunicación de los Lugares de Memoria Histórica y Democrática en Cádiz’, in Rossiya i Iberoamerika v globaliziruyushchemsya mire: istoriya i sovremennost’ [Russia and Iberoamerica in a Globalizing World: Past and Present]: Conference Proceedings. Saint Petersburg: Skifia-print, pp. 1738–1744.

26. Koroleva, A., Kadyrova, K. and Knyazheva, M. (2020) ‘The interpretation of the democratic memory locations in Cadiz by Instagram users’, Latin-american Historical Almanac, 25(1), pp. 58–71. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.32608/2305-8773-2020-25-1-58-71

27. Macé, J.-F. (2012) ‘Los conflictos de memoria en la España post-franquista (1976-2010)’, Bulletin hispanique, (114–2), pp. 749–774. https://doi.org/10.4000/bulletinhispanique.2150

28. Molinero, C. (2007) ‘La política de reconciliación nacional. Su contenido durante el franquismo, su lectura en la Transición’, Ayer, (66), pp. 201–225.

29. Moradiellos E. (2004) 1936. Los mitos de la Guerra Civil. Barcelona: Península.

30. Preston, P. (2013) El holocausto español: Odio y exterminio en la Guerra Civil y después. Barcelona: Debolsillo.

31. Renshaw, L. (2009) ‘Uncovered: reversals of exposure and concealment in Spain’s memory politics’, New Literary Observer, (6), pp. 475–493. (In Russian).

32. Richards, M. and Ealham, C. (2005) ‘History, Memory and the Spanish Civil War: Recent Perspectives’, in The splintering of Spain: cultural history and the Spanish Civil War, 1936-193. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 1–20.

33. Santacreu Soler, J. M. (2016) La recuperació de la memòria històrica al País Valencià: reparar i dignificar les víctimes amb les subvencions estatals (2006-2011). Castelló de la Plana: Universitat Jaume I; Universitat d’Alacant; Universitat de València.

34. Sevillano Calero, F. (2007) ‘El revisionismo historiográfico, sobre el pasado reciente en España’, Pasado y memoria, (6), pp. 183–190. https://doi.org/10.14198/PASADO2007.6.10

35. Torres Fabra, R. C. and Navarro Navarro, J. F. (2012) ‘Franquisme, repressió, memòria... el treball dels historiadors’, in Temps de por al País Valencià (1938-1975): estudis sobre la repressió franquista. Castelló: Universitat Jaume I, pp. 7–21.