Do Shia-Sunni Tensions Affect Iranian-Saudi Relations?

Today the rivalry between Iran and Saudi Arabia is one of the defining factors in the Middle East political arena. The Islamic world's division into Shiite and Sunni is often considered a factor affecting bilateral relations between Tehran and Riyadh. Iran positions itself as the center of gravity for all the Shiites in the region, while Saudi Arabia seeks to form an anti-Iranian alliance on a Sunni basis. This article assesses the impact of the doctrinal tensions between these two branches of Islam on the Iranian approach towards its relations with Saudi Arabia. For this purpose, the author analyses the rhetoric of Iranian officials, clerics, and state-run media in the context of the main concepts of the Iranian contemporary religious ideology. The author concludes that criticism of Saudi Arabia has lost its religious connotation and Tehran does not position its confrontation with Riyadh as a fight against the enemies of Islam or apostates. The traditional epithets classifying their holders as supporters of the forces of darkness and actively used against the Western countries and Israel are not cited by critics of the Saudi dynasty. Moreover, the criticism of Wahhabism as a religious movement is not linked to the kingdom's current political leadership. On the contrary, the Iranian criticism of the Saudi foreign and domestic policies focuses on condemning the Saudi authorities' infringement on human rights and media freedom, supporting the protest movement in Iran, and fighting the Houthis. Even the persecution of Shiites in Saudi Arabia, to which the Iranian press has devoted considerable attention, is viewed from the perspective of the global concept of human rights, rather than as the struggle of one religious group against another. The kingdom itself is not considered an ideological enemy of Iran, which since the Islamic Revolution has been the US and Israel. The statements by some representatives of the Iranian political establishment on the need for peaceful coexistence between the two countries, along with the March 2023 agreements on normalizing bilateral relations indicate Tehran's pragmatic approach to interaction with Riyadh which is not affected by the ShiaSunni controversy in its dogmatic and religious dimensions.

1. Akhmedov, V. M. and Kulagina, L. M. (2021) Osnovnye napravleniya politiki IRI v arabskih stranah Blizhnego Vostoka (1990-e – nachalo 2020-h gg.) [Main Directions of the IRI’s Policy in the Arab Countries of the Middle East (1990s early 2020s)]. Moscow: Institut vostokovedeniya RAN Publ. (In Russian).

2. Chikrizova, O. S. (2015) ‘On the methodology of research of sunni-shiite relations’, Bulletin of Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia. Series International relations, 15(3), pp. 74–82. (In Russian).

3. Chikrizova, O. S. (2017) ‘“Oppressed — oppressors” dichotomy in shiʻite perception of international relations’, Friendship University of Russia. Series International relations, 17(2), pp. 279–289. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.22363/2313-0660-2017-17-2-279-289

4. Doroshenko, E. A. (1998) Shiitskoe duhovenstvo v dvuh revolyuciyah: 1905–1911 i 1978–1979 gg [The Shiite clergy in two revolutions: 1905–1911 and 1978–1979]. Moscow: IV RAN Publ. (In Russian).

5. Filin, N. A. (2017) ‘Conflict of Old and New Religious Forms in the Iranian Political Life of after the Islamic Revolution of 1979’, Vlastʹ, 25(11), pp. 107–110. (In Russian).

6. Kosach, G. G. (2017) ‘Saudovskaya Araviya: «religioznoe gosudarstvo» ili «gosudarstvennaya religiya»? [Saudi Arabia: “Religious State” or “State Religion”?]’, Religiâ i obŝestvo na Vostoke, (1), pp. 7–50. (In Russian).

7. Kuznetsov, A. A. (2021) Sunnitsko-shiitskie protivorechiya v kontekste geopolitiki regiona Blizhnego Vostoka (1979–2016) [Sunni-Shiite Contradictions in the Context of the Geopolitics of the Middle East Region (1979–2016)]. Moscow: Universitet Dmitriya Pozharskogo Publ. (In Russian).

8. Mesamed, V. I. (2009) Iran-Izrail: ot partnerstva k konfliktu [Iran-Israel: From Partnership to Conflict]. Moscow: In-t Blizhnego Vostoka Publ. (In Russian).

9. Osiewicz, P. (2020) Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. London: Routledge. https://doi. org/10.4324/9781003018285

10. Rezaei, F. (2019) Iran’s Foreign Policy After the Nuclear Agreement: Politics of Normalizers and Traditionalists. Cham: Springer International Publishing; Palgrave Macmillan (Middle East Today). https://doi. org/10.1007/978-3-319-76789-5

11. Seliktar, O. and Rezaei, F. (2020) Iran, Revolution, and Proxy Wars. Cham: Springer International Publishing: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-29418-2

12. Svistunova, I. A. (2019) ‘Turkish-Iranian Relations in the Middle East: in Search of the Regional Balance’, MGIMO Review of International Relations, 12(4), pp. 130–144. (In Russian). 10.24833/2071-8160-2019-4-67130-144. https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2019-4-67-130-144

13. Vasiliev, A. M. (1999) Istoriya Saudovskoj Aravii (1745 g. – konec XX v.) [The History of Saudi Arabia (1745 – end of XX century)]. Moscow: Klassika plus Publ. (In Russian).

14. Zaccara, L. (ed.) (2020) Foreign Policy of Iran under President Hassan Rouhani’s First Term (2013– 2017). Singapore: Springer Singapore; Palgrave Macmillan (Contemporary Gulf Studies). https://doi. org/10.1007/978-981-15-3924-4

15. Zhilina, I. Y. (2020) ‘Katar: itogi trehletnej ekonomicheskoj blokady (2017–2020) [Qatar: the results of the three-year economic blockade (2017–2020)]’, Èkonomičeskie, socialʹno-političeskie, ètnokonfessionalʹnye problemy afro-aziatskih stran, (3), pp. 194–205. (In Russian).